Monday, January 28, 2013

What Happens When there are 6 Accident Victims and Only 1 Insurance Policy

   What happens when there are 6 victims in the same car accident and there is only one insurance policy covering the responsible driver.  Unfortunately, this happens.

   In the past, attorneys representing each accident victim would race to be first to the insurer with the result being that, after the first 2 claims, there was no more insurance.  The insurance had been exhausted and the remaining victims were left out in the cold.

   In a case,  Williams v. GEICO, http://www.courts.alaska.gov/ops/sp-6746.pdf, published last Friday, January 25, the Alaska Supreme Court established a new rule.  Instead of settling the cases which raced to the courthouse first and then closing their file, insurers are now required to attempt to resolve all claims if possible.    What does this mean for accident victims.

1.   If you are in a serious accident, you still need to be represented by a lawyer sooner rather than later.  Otherwise, your interest is not represented.

2.   If insurance is limited, it is possible that the insurer (or a court) will prorate the insurance according to each individual's losses.  In this case, you will need to present your losses for purposes of securing a maximum, albeit inadequate, recovery.

3.   You will need to carefully examine all other sources of insurance.  Most often this additional insurance will be found in Underinsured Motorist coverages applicable to the vehicle, in your own name, and in the name of other household members.

4.   You will need to determine  whether the limits of multiple insurance policies can be stacked.

You have to play your hand smartly and it gets complicated quickly.  See www.Junelawyer.com


Thursday, January 10, 2013

Voyages of Discovery or Fishing Expeditions: Your Lawyer's Fight for Evidence

    A client does not receive compensation for his injuries just because there was an accident.  Rather, the client must establish that the responsible party was negligent, i.e., made a mistake that should not have been made.  This can only be done through evidence.  Unfortunately, it is the responsible party, not the client, that, most often, controls this evidence. Once a lawsuit is filed, the lawyer must obtain this evidence through the process called "Discovery"  in which responsible parties are supposedly required to "voluntarily disclose" relevant evidence as well as provide additional evidence formally requested by the accident victim's lawyer.

    In fact, important evidence is not provided voluntarily and defense lawyers regularly call efforts to locate that evidence through documents and witness depositions as "fishing expeditions."  Recent experience shows why this is not true and why accident victim lawyers must work hard to discover all important evidence..

    In a case in which insurer misconduct led to the total loss of a client's business, basic policy manuals and documents guiding its employees were not provided.  Because every business in the modern world has basic policy manuals, the insurer was asked to do so.  In response, the defense lawyer represented that there were no such documents.  (Actually, the defense lawyer first said that he did not understand what evidence was being requested and that basic policy manuals had no bearing on the case, calling the request a "fishing expedition" but when the Court finally ordered the policy manuals to be provided said there were none.  One wonders why he did not say so in the first place but that is a different subject).  Not surprisingly, when the first witness was asked the same question, the witness described a series of policy manuals. How can this happen?

    I would like to believe that the defense lawyer was not dishonest but that economic incentives of the legal system lead to the defense lawyer being improperly ignorant.  Because relevant evidence will lead to the responsible party paying damages, the responsible party has the economic incentive to be "Clintonesque, i.e., to feign ignorance by pretending either that one does not understand what evidence is being sought or by pretending that one does not have the knowledge to appreciate where the evidence is.  After all, promotions and bonuses are given for bringing money in, not paying money out to accident victims.  At some level, my guess is that defense lawyers also appreciate this but have the same economic incentive to be improperly ignorant, i.e., defense lawyers are paid by their clients to trust the client's word and "fight" to protect their clients from paying money to accident victims.  While one may hope that the defense lawyer follows a higher standard and makes his own independent best efforts to locate relevant evidence that does not happen.   When relevant evidence is uncovered, defense lawyers regularly say that, had they known about the evidence, it would have been disclosed. The important question is how could they not know about the evidence? 

    There is a reason that Columbus' expeditions to the New World were called "Voyages of Discovery" and not "Voyages of Confirmation" or "Fishing Expeditions."  Columbus knew something was out there, just not the exact form of what he would find.  The same is true for lawyers in discovery seeking evidence to help  accident victims.  It is because the lawyer cannot trust responsible parties to voluntarily provide evidence important to establishing legal responsibility that the lawyer must be thorough.  See WWW. JUNELAWYER.COM


Monday, December 10, 2012

Be Wary of Free Seminars Following Multiple Victim Accidents


     There was a tragic accident on the Seward Highway North of  Girdwood in which 11 persons were injured.  See "Crash Near Girdwood Closes Seward Highway," http://www.adn.com/2012/12/09/2718960/crash-near-girdwood-closes-seward.html.

      It is not unusual following an accident for accident victims to receive phone calls or mailings promising "no charge" health care or a "no charge" seminar on their rights.  Accident victims should be wary of these solicitations.   A multiple victim accident such as this will trigger many legal issues.  These include:

1.  An investigation of the facts (Most often provided by the Alaska Trooper Report)
2.  An assessment of the available liability insurance coverage.  With multiple victims, this insurance may be inadequate to compensate each victim individually.
3.  An assessment whether any of the victims may be accused of bearing partial responsibility.  Most often, this is directed to the driver of the vehicle.
4.  An assessment of injuries.
5.  An assessment of losses.
6.  An assessment of other insurance coverages such as Underinsured Motorist.

While these are the legal issues, the most important issue is recovery from injuries, something that is addressed by a physician, not a lawyer.  I recommend that accident victims make medical treatment their highest priority, even higher priority than meeting with my office.   When life deals you a low card in the form of an accident, you have to play your hand smartly.  See www.Junelawyer.com.
.



Monday, November 19, 2012

Workers Compensation Liens: The Client's Duty to Repay and the Employer's Future Credit

   When a person suffers a work injury, he receives workers' compensation benefits.  These include both payment of medical benefits as well as payments of Disability Benefits.  Over time, there may be other benefits such as partial impairment benefits and vocational retraining benefits.

    When the work injury is caused by someone other than the employer, the worker has a "third party claim."  
Should the worker be successful in recovering his losses from this party, the worker has 3 duties to his employer and its workers' compensation insurer.

1.  The worker must obtain the employer's consent to settlement.  If  the worker fails to do this, the employer  is no longer responsible for paying workers' compensation benefits.   This is true even if the "settlement"  means the worker is giving up on his case.

2.  The worker must pay back any worker's compensation benefits.

3.   If the worker is able to recover more than he has received in workers's compensation benefits, the remaining amounts serve as a credit against future workers' compensation benefits.

While actual results depend on the facts of the specific case, a lawyer can negotiate a reduction of the worker's compensation "pay back."  At a minimum, the workers' compensation insurer must pay the pro rata share of any legal fees incurred to recover the pay back amounts.  Beyond this, a workers' compensation insurer may be willing to further reduce the pay back if the injured worker is willing to agree not to receive further workers' compensation benefits.

While one cannot predict the result in all cases, you have to play your hand smartly.  See www.Junelawyer.com.


Tuesday, November 6, 2012

Motorcycle Fatality Due to Improper Conduct by State of Alaska DOT

     Last week, I was able to successfully negotiate the settlement of a motorcycle fatality case against the State of Alaska, Department of Transportation ("DOT").  The basis of DOT responsibility was DOT workers' failure to clean up after asphalt repair with the result being that the motorcyclist lost control of his bike on small pieces of gravel entering a sharp curve.

     Clients often ask about what makes a case strong and what makes a case weak.  Here are  what I considered to be some of the keys to success in this case.

1.   Photographic confirmation of asphalt repair work (DOT workers could not remember what work they did except in the most general terms)

2.   Neutral witness confirmation of hazardous road conditions specifically on the day and time of the accident.(DOT workers simply denied they would ever do shoddy work)

3.    Photographic and record corroboration of neutral witness testimony. (In this case, one witness actually called DOT to complain and there was a record confirming the phone call).

4.    The deceased having a clean traffic citation history so as to rebut accusations of reckless driving. (Rightly or wrongly, there is a stereotype of motorcylists).

5.    The deceased driving a touring motorcycle while wearing helmet and leathers.

6.    Advising the clients how the case could be lost despite strong facts.   One consideration in this case is that a jury deciding a claim against a government entity appreciates that the verdict will be paid from tax dollars.  Just as a popular television commercial says "Its our Oil!" the jury will be saying "Its our Money."

The motorcyclists family were deserving clients and I was happy that I could help them.  In my opinion, they played their hand smartly.





Monday, October 1, 2012

The Result of A Successful Appeal: Retrial

     Last week, the Alaska Supreme Court Opinion in my Case, Thompson v. Central Plumbing was issued.
The Supreme Court held that the Trial Court had made a mistake in not allowing my client's doctors to testify that his serious injury was caused by a T-Bone collision and that the Trial Court had made an additional mistake in not instructing the jury that the negligent driver was also responsible for any medical mistakes that the defense doctor testified was the alternate explanation for the client's injuries.    As a result of not being allowed to hear relevant evidence and to be properly instructed on the law, the jury, returned an unfair verdict.
     Clients sometimes misunderstand what it means to "win" on appeal.  In this case, the "win" does not mean that my client will soon be paid a fair amount for his injuries.  Instead, it means that the first trial is considered to be a "mulligan" and that there is a "do-over" of the trial with respect to damages.  This client's case has been a long journey with the appeal, alone, taking 2 years of time.  Now, he is waiting for a second trial, free from the mistakes of the first trial, which most likely will be scheduled within the next year.
     It is the long wait that requires clients to play their hand smartly.  However, sometimes they have no choice but to pursue their remedies to the end.  See www.Junelawyer.com

Monday, September 17, 2012

How Legal Consultation is Helpful

   This weekend's Anchorage Daily News contained an article about a young man involved in a serious motor vehicle accident that resulted in catastrophic injuries in a situation in which the responsible driver most likely had minimal insurance.  See http://community.adn.com/adn/node/162381  In cases in which the responsible driver has inadequate insurance, clients ask what possible help a lawyer can be.  Here are some of the steps a lawyer will take to try and help the injured person.

1.  Investigate the existence of other Insurance policies that could potentially provide coverage for the injuries and losses.
2.  Recover the available insurance of the responsible driver.
3.  Investigate the potential responsibilities of persons other than the driver.
4.  Assist in filing an Underinsured/Uninsured Motorist Claim under the insurance of the injured person..
5.  Investigate the possibility of additional Underinsured/Uninsured Motorist insurance coverage.
6.  Negotiate discounts and forgiveness of liens of medical providers, health insurers, Medicare and Medicaid.

Of course, depending on the specific facts, there may be other issues.   In catastrophic accidents, it is even more important to play your hand smartly.  See www.Junelawyer.com